Monday, March 29, 2010

10 Things You Should NOT Ask a Freelance Writer

By now, Mr. Muse and most people in my immediate circle know better than to ask questions of the "why haven't you published any books yet?" and "when are you getting a real job?" variety. But these types of questions come up frequently when I meet people who aren't as familiar with the concept of freelancing.

As I suspected, I'm far from alone in this. An informal poll among my Twitter followers and Facebook fans turned up lots of questions we wish people would stop asking already. Here's a roundup of questions and some (far too cheeky for actual use) answers.

  1. How come you never write for "real" magazines? Several years ago, I had a roommate ask this question, and it bugged the $%@& out of me. (We no longer live together.) She meant "how come you write for all these niche publications I've never heard of?" Newstand magazines are only a fraction of all the potential freelance markets, and they are highly competitive. Now that I've written for a few consumer magazines, I can say that while the clips are nice, they can take a lot more work for the same amount of money I can earn writing for a trade or custom magazine. I say there's no shame in these under-the-radar markets!

  2. If you earn $1/word, shouldn't you be a millionaire by now? If I had a dollar for every time someone asked that, I would be a millionaire. (Not really, but I thought it was a clever retort.) Some magazines pay $1/word, but word counts have shrunk and that per word rate hasn't increased in decades. Plus, there's a lot more that goes into an article than the actual writing. There's also querying, researching, tracking down sources, following up with sources, locating images, fact-checking, rewriting, invoicing, and so on.

  3. How's the job hunt? (via @tinahernandez) This is a common question, especially now with so many laid-off workers freelancing while they job hunt. But many freelancers (including @tinahernandez and yours truly) have no interest in returning to the 8-6 grind. I usually point out that since I can pick my own projects and make a comfortable living on my own, I don't need a traditional job.

  4. My kid needs his speech written for school, can you help? (via @salmajafri) I've never gotten this one, but I'd be tempted to point out that hiring a professional writer might get the kid an A, but it won't make him any smarter. (Yes, I know the parent is probably hoping for a freebie, but that's not how I roll.) @salmajafri is far more generous and told me she might help out with bullet points.

  5. When does your book come out? (via @storyfella) I've had plenty of people suggest that writing a book is my golden ticket to success or ask if I have a novel in the works. But books represent only a sliver of opportunity for writers, and the combination of shrinking advances and rising competition make it hard for writers to support themselves solely on books. Sure, many of us have a novel in our heads or on our hard drives, but we also write articles, blog posts, press releases, and catalogues to pay the bills.

  6. Can you edit my _____ for me as a favor? (via @HeiddiZ) In a word: no. We have to support ourselves, too, and too many favors cuts into our bottom line. Sure, I've proofread my brother's cover letters and helped my Mom revamp her resume, but these are close family members who understand that paying work has to be the priority and that they don't get unlimited freebies.

  7. What are you doing? Why don't you meet me for lunch? (via Diane Faulkner) Variations on this theme asking requests for rides to the airport, signatures on FedEx packages (that aren't yours), or helping with other daytime chores. Sometimes it's nice to get a change of scenery and meet a friend for lunch or help out when someone really needs it, but the presumption that freelancers have nothing better to than sit around waiting for the FedEx guy or meet you for lunch gets old. Fast.

  8. So do you go to the shops/cinema/for a walk/for lunch out all day? (via @HOHWWriter) Similar to #7 but no less annoying. I pointed out to @HOHWWriter that sometimes we do get to do these things during the work day if it's for an assignment. But it's far from the leisurely, two martini lunches that some people picture. While scoping out a new restaurant or store, I'm also furiously scribbling notes in the dressing room or coaxing the owner into letting me snap a few photos if she doesn't have any. Believe me - there is a lot work involved.

  9. Do I get to read/approve the article before it runs? (via @roxannehawn) This is a question that I get from more sources than acquaintances. But it comes up often enough that it deserves a mention. When you show a story to a source, it can turn into a runaway buggy where they're trying take the reins and rewrite your article to reflect their company agenda. This blog post from Jake Poinier offer a tactful explanation of why sources and PR folks don't need to see the article in advance. (But as he points out in the comments, asking to confirm quotes is totally acceptable.)

  10. You're a freelance writer. So does that mean you work for free? (via @JoanneMasonESL) File under: "are you freaking kidding me?!" Enough said.

Anything else you would add? How would you respond to these questions?

Flickr photo courtesy of carolyntiry

25 comments:

Keith Schoch said...

As a blogger I get this a lot! Check out my related post at http://howtoteachanovel.blogspot.com/2010/03/real-writers-only-need-apply.html.

New medium, new type of writers. Get that straight in your heads, folks!

The Red Angel said...

A good list. I'm still young in my writing career (only 17), but I know that if people did ask me one or more of these questions later on in life, I would definitely be ticked off.

I already do get comments similar to these questions from those who believe writing isn't a "good enough job."

People don't seem to understand that freelance writers do what they do because they LOVE what they do, unlike some people who go to medical school just for the big money and because they got straight A's in all their high school and college science classes.

Callie Lorentson said...

I would add:

People you meet at a party who tell you, "Oh, you're a writer? Well I've got a great idea for a story you should write about...if you write this book about [up-ended turtles, two hobos eating Spam, a guy and a cylon walk into a bar, etc.,] I guarantee you'll make a million dollars. And then you can split it with me for giving you the great idea. Your Welcome. [Person then mentally pats self on the back.]

Callie
@frugalseattle

Susan said...

This made me laugh. I understand it all too well. When I was a full-time freelance travel writer, everyone thought I was rich b/c I got to go on press trips for free. When in reality, they had no idea I could be gone a week but get paid a paltry flat fee for the article itself. I was essentially losing money to go, but it was a lifestyle choice and a building block. And I would still have to pay to tip for the 'free' massages I was getting, snowmobile rides, etc.

I've also written 4 guide books and even then, I knew it was not my golden ticket to fame and fortune, but a stepping stone to diversify my career and establish myself as an expert.

I've written for big glossy magazines and established newspapers, and also small regional mags. I've found the more I'm diversifying, the easier it gets. I would not want to put all my eggs in one basket. You need a well-rounded arsenal of clips and projects to be successful.

Laurie said...

How about, "Can you write an article about the church, kids' activities, my neighbor's life...for the local paper (not even the large city paper I write for)." Many people think that if you write for "the paper" you write any paper and will automatically coordinate any and all information for any group with which you are affiliated. I've also had the request to read college essays of the kids of "friends" (the same friends who ask my doctor-husband to sign medical forms at the last minute). Nice to see that others experience the same! Thanks, Susan

Colette said...

I'll add to your list. My favorite (from my mother) is:

"Are your looking for a job, or still just biding your time?"

James Frey said...

Another one -- Will you write my blog for my business? I get a little offended when people suggest that blogs are something that can be ghostwritten. Blogs are supposed to be genuine.

-- storyfella (aka James frey)

Jesaka Long said...

Oh, I felt my blood boil when I saw "How's the job hunt?" Clearly, that's my button. In addition to hearing it because of all the interim freelancers, I hear this from a few family members, too. They just can't grasp that I'm a freelancer--and it doesn't seem to work if I explain it as "I have my own company."

Anyway, thanks for the opportunity to rant. That feels much better. I really enjoyed your post. It made me laugh!

Sandy said...

Hiring a writer for the kid's speech is really funny...A good list...

Lori said...

These have me howling with laughter!!

I get the "real" magazine one, which I answer with, "Well gee, since these 'fake' ones pay me over a dollar a word, I don't really see why I should bother with that 'real' one that pays 25 cents a word..."

I get the kid/essay request all the time. Worse, I write resumes, which has led to more than my share of "tweak this for me" - brazen people who send it in an attachment without asking. I usually say "Sure! I can get to it in two days and my fee is..."

The "favor editing" one - I had an interesting twist to that. The client sent over a picture and said, "If you were to connect this to my book tour, what kind of caption would you put on it?" I told her the price for captions was XXX. She did it herself. :)

I LOATHE the "We need to approve this before it prints" because most times I get this, it's in the form of a demand AFTER the interview. That's when I refer them to the editor. Let them strong-arm someone who has no intention of being bossed around!

Chantal said...

Great post!

My favorite: someone calling me at 10 a.m. on a weekday and asking "did I just wake you up?". Please. I get up and start working at 8.30 am just like the 9 to 5ers. Only difference is, I can do it in my pajamas.

Joanne Mason said...

Great list!

I get the "did I just wake you up?" question quite frequently. Grrr.... : )

Also, I remember telling a neighbor what kind of writing I do (mainly ESL-related educational materials right now), she looked disappointed and said, "Ohhh. I thought you WROTE wrote."

Her boyfriend said, "She does write."

And my neighbor said, "No, I mean REAL writing."

Another grrrr....

Jake P. said...

Great stuff, Susan. Thanks for the link in #9--I've cross-posted you over at Jake's Takes :)

It's not a question about freelancing per se, but I would add an asterisk for when I was in college and people would ask, "English major? Whaddayagonna do with that, be a TEACHER?"

Fortunately, having been in the business for almost 11 years now, I see these types of comments for their humor rather than horror...

Natalia M. Sylvester said...

Oh wow, where do I start?! I've been asked all these questions (even the signing for Fedex one)!

@Jake: In college my journalism professor, after hearing I was an English major asked me: "Have you thought about joining the army?"

I have a strict policy that I only check family's work for them, but only if I really can. If it's given to me on short notice I just tell them I'll try my best and get to it if I can.

The problem with the word "freelancer" as you all pointed out, is that everyone assumes we're looking for "real" jobs. This is why I removed the word from my business cards and website. Now I'm just "copywriter and editor," which has worked pretty well. Since I use a separate email for pitching magazines (and the mag world understands the concept better) I keep freelance writer on that one.

Another one I get is: "Do you have any other jobs? Is that actually your full-time job?" I understand many do this part-time, but if you ask me what I do for a living and I answer, I'm a freelance writer, then that means it's what I do for a living, right?

Andrea V. Lewis said...

This wouldn't be funny if it wasn't so true. Great post Susan. As someone who is freelance writing as I job hunt I can relate! I especially liked how you integrated responses from friends/followers/readers from other platforms. Doing so provides a really robust and humanizing piece for others to relate to.

Thanks for sharing!

Brian V. Hunt said...

It's similar to when I wrote for the games industry. People would ask, "So you pretty much just play games all day?" After a while, I'd just reply, "Yeah. Cool, huh?"

Valerie Alexander said...

#6 and #7 are a plague upon my existence. I've had people (some I barely know!) ask if I could help them with everything from a web site to an entire book. And way too many people think I can babysit in a pinch if needed.

I also get asked outright how much money I make. Excuse me, but when did that become an acceptable question? My 9 to 5'er friends don't get asked that. It's rude no matter what someone's occupation.

Great list!

Jen said...

"What does a writer do?"

The number of times I've been asked this at social events is unbelievable. That someone could be paid to write is unbelievable, apparently.

I specialise in web writing so I'm often asked if I can fix up someone's HTML or blog. When I've gone on to specify that I create the copy for websites I've had a couple of outraged, "You COPY? But isn't that plagiarism?"

Isao said...

Interesting...I just read similar story at CatalystBlogger http://ow.ly/1t0RZ. "I've often been expected to pick up the slack for chores, housework and errands because I work from home."

Alisa Bowman said...

1. I have a great idea for a novel. Will you write it for me? I can pay you $25.

2. So you only do nonfiction? You don't aspire to more?

3. I'm thinking of becoming a writer. Would you care to share any tips?

Steph said...

Maybe we're being a bit too sensitive. After all, I'm a freelancer, and I certainly take the time to have lunch with friends every so often. You'd have a lunch break in the corporate and you need to eat. Why be so offended when someone wants to dine with you? It doesn't have to be a suggestion that you have more free time than everyone else.

Susan Johnston said...

@Steph: Good point! When it strays from "let's do lunch" to "will you let in the FedEx guy/pick up my kids/take me to the airport", then it certainly sends the message that the other person thinks you sit around all day.

Fibro Witch said...

My least personal favorite, "Can you introduce me to X?" Yes I do write about some well known people. That does not mean I have them on speed dial. I can't call Mr X or Ms Y and request they take some time out of there busy day to entertain some one I barely know.

Carole Lee said...

My personal favorite: "Have you found a job yet?"

Everyone thinks working from home makes me jobless. Worse, they also think I can drop what I'm doing to chat on the phone. I've considered changing my schedule to sleep days and work nights. At least the phone wouldn't ring all day. I've had neighbors bang on the door incessantly when I didn't answer the phone the three times they called. I'm at WORK, people!

FB @ FabulouslyBroke.com said...

As a freelancing IT consultant, I particularly hate

1. How's the job hunt
2. Oh, so you're unemployed
3. Why don't you have a real job
4. I guess you sit at home on your ass all day
5. Do you earn *anything*?

I smile, because I now earn roughly 3-4x what I ever earned before as an employee.

Related Posts with Thumbnails